Analyze Catalogue Methodology Blog Pro Access

⚡ Interrogation des APIs scientifiques en cours…

The quality score for scientific publications. 100% free, 100% independent.

Navigation

Home
Analyze an article
Methodology
Blog
My account

Transparency

Our independence
Methodological transparency
Pro Access
Contact us
Legal notice
Privacy
ToU
ToS
Glossary

Developers

Public API
GitHub

Free score, forever.

C (55/100) — À nuancer | Shai I et al. | Publi-Score

Weight loss with a low-carbohydrate, Mediterranean, or low-fat diet

Shai I et al.·New England Journal of Medicine·Jul 2008·PMID 18635428

Authors' conclusion

Mixed

Does not affect the score

Publi-Score

55/100

NuancedLast updated: 4/18/2026

Fidelity

Abstract only65% concordance × 24/26 subcriteria

Category breakdown

Total raw score42.5/100

Integrity coefficient

A. Authors' integrity

COI declaration

0.50

Funding independence

0.85

Coeff. authors = avg(0.50, 0.85) = 0.68

B. Editorial process

Peer review

1.00

Submission→accept. delay

0.90

Coeff. editorial = avg(1.00, 0.90) = 0.95

min(0.68, 0.95) = 0.68← lowest dominates

🚫

Alert signal : eoc → Coefficient forced to 0.3

Expression of Concern published

Final coefficient : 0.68

Final score = 42.5/52.8 × 0.68 × 100 = 55/100

Save

📄 Export PDF

PubMed DOI

Twitter/X LinkedIn

Contribute

Actions

Analyze another article View the methodology

Information

PMID: 18635428
DOI: 10.1056/NEJMoa0708681

Mode

🔬 Partial AI (abstract)

Grid

v1.1

Scored on

4/18/2026

Impact Factor

52.6

Quartile

Similar publications

C50/100

Weight loss, exercise, or both and physical function in obese older adults.

Villareal DT — 2011 · The New England journal of medicine

B69/100

Calorie Restriction with or without Time-Restricted Eating in Weight Loss.

Liu D — 2022 · New England Journal of Medicine

B66/100

Once-Weekly Semaglutide in Adults with Overweight or Obesity

Wilding JPH — 2021 · The New England Journal of Medicine